Bookfest: Time for Slow Change
Mon, Oct. 20th, 2003 09:03 am::Rant Warning::
A number of friends of mine who attended the Pacific Northwest Bookfest this weekend remarked that attendance was down significantly from last year. This morning, the Seattle Times ran a piece about the sparse attendance, citing mainly the new $10 admission fee as a cause.
While money wasn't the reason I didn't attend (crowd exhaustion, beautiful weather, and other plans kept me away), I can certainly understand how, in a lousy economy where jobs are scarce, a $10 admission could scare people off. In previous years, the Bookfest requested a $5.00 donation. If they'd made that donation the admission fee, rather than leaping to twice the price right off, they might have garnered a higher attendance. Next year they might have boosted it to $7.00.
What also puzzles me is why science fiction conventions can charge $50-$60 for attendance and still fill a hotel to overflowing while a larger festival with a broader appeal can't pack the place at a relatively modest fee. What do they need to do to change that? I'm not sure. Perhaps it's the setting? Perhaps it's a matter of customer investment, i.e., positioning their admission fee as a membership? I don't know.
My feeling is that they were looking at a deficit in their budget and panicked. I'm sure that fundraising has taken a hit in this economy (just like everything else), so they probably figured that jacking up the admission was the easiest way to go. It cost them, though, and it could cost the Pacific Northwest as well.
My question is: is this sort of quick fix really doing anyone any good? PNW Bookfest has suffered from curiously disorganized management (at least that's how it's looked from the outside) and impermanent facilities over the last few years. Positioned in one of the most literate regions in the country, however, it's got a stalwart following, and a huge network of booksellers, publishers and authors to keep it going. It just seems as though trying to come up with a quick answer rather than taking the long view and solving their problems gradually is imprudent at best and, at worst, could end the festival for good. And that, my friends, would be a loss to us all.
::End of Rant::
A number of friends of mine who attended the Pacific Northwest Bookfest this weekend remarked that attendance was down significantly from last year. This morning, the Seattle Times ran a piece about the sparse attendance, citing mainly the new $10 admission fee as a cause.
While money wasn't the reason I didn't attend (crowd exhaustion, beautiful weather, and other plans kept me away), I can certainly understand how, in a lousy economy where jobs are scarce, a $10 admission could scare people off. In previous years, the Bookfest requested a $5.00 donation. If they'd made that donation the admission fee, rather than leaping to twice the price right off, they might have garnered a higher attendance. Next year they might have boosted it to $7.00.
What also puzzles me is why science fiction conventions can charge $50-$60 for attendance and still fill a hotel to overflowing while a larger festival with a broader appeal can't pack the place at a relatively modest fee. What do they need to do to change that? I'm not sure. Perhaps it's the setting? Perhaps it's a matter of customer investment, i.e., positioning their admission fee as a membership? I don't know.
My feeling is that they were looking at a deficit in their budget and panicked. I'm sure that fundraising has taken a hit in this economy (just like everything else), so they probably figured that jacking up the admission was the easiest way to go. It cost them, though, and it could cost the Pacific Northwest as well.
My question is: is this sort of quick fix really doing anyone any good? PNW Bookfest has suffered from curiously disorganized management (at least that's how it's looked from the outside) and impermanent facilities over the last few years. Positioned in one of the most literate regions in the country, however, it's got a stalwart following, and a huge network of booksellers, publishers and authors to keep it going. It just seems as though trying to come up with a quick answer rather than taking the long view and solving their problems gradually is imprudent at best and, at worst, could end the festival for good. And that, my friends, would be a loss to us all.
::End of Rant::