Theater: Love Never Dies
Sun, May. 13th, 2018 07:06 pmOn Friday night, I saw LOVE NEVER DIES (Andrew Lloyd-Webber's sequel to PHANTOM OF THE OPERA) and have been thinking hard about it. I had reservations going in because the show has gotten . . . uneven review. The evening flew for me and that doesn't happen unless I've enjoyed a show. Here are some thoughts about it in no particular order:
The show opens with a number so big and so melodramatic that it could have closed the first act; I felt as though Lloyd-Webber was setting the emotional starting line so high that I'd be exhausted halfway through Act One. The projected image of Christine during that song felt like it was there to MAKE SURE I UNDERSTOOD who the Phantom was singing about. I didn't find it quite as ridiculous as the two-story translucent portraits projected during act two of THE BODYGUARD, but it came close.
I liked the transition of the story to Coney Island at the turn of the century. It gave the show its own character, even though the music thematically linked it to PHANTOM. It retained an otherworldliness without repeating the original show's setting.
The costumes and staging were uniformly very good indeed. Christine's final gown was a blue peacock fantasy, just gorgeous. The carnival costumes worked very well.
The voices were all splendid, but Meghan Picerno, who played Christine, was astonishing, sweeping the stratosphere with her coloratura. Gardar Thor Cortes, as the Phantom, had pipes that could have blown down the walls. As I progress with my voice lessons, I'm listening to and watching singers much more closely, and it's been fun to recognize techniques here and there that I've been talking about with my teacher.
Toward the end of the first act, the BIGNESS of the music began to wear on me. Intermission came just a smidge too late for me not to feel it. Every now and then I found myself thinking that the lyrics were remarkably pedestrian; I wanted a little more poetry. There were a coupe of moments that were supposed to be dramatic but provoked inappropriate laughter from more than just me. I saw the big reveal in the first act long before it came. Developments in the second act unwound in an interesting but not especially original way, although I *was* surprised by the twist at the end, not that it happened but when and how it happened.
In the end, though, as I said above, the evening did fly for me, so I enjoyed the show despite its shortcomings: melodramatic, overwrought, big Big BIG music. Sometimes, it just works anyway.
I'm still hearing the show's eponymous tune, "Love Never Dies" in my head. It, along with "Look with Your Heart" (which, I think, is sort of the point of the whole show), "Beneath a Moonless Sky," "Once Upon Another Time," "Dear Old Friend," "Bathing Beauty" and "Devil Take the Hindmost" were the most distinctive numbers, and stand out among the rest. My criticism of the lyrics and the melodrama still stands but, say what you will about Lloyd-Webber, he knows his business very well indeed.
The show opens with a number so big and so melodramatic that it could have closed the first act; I felt as though Lloyd-Webber was setting the emotional starting line so high that I'd be exhausted halfway through Act One. The projected image of Christine during that song felt like it was there to MAKE SURE I UNDERSTOOD who the Phantom was singing about. I didn't find it quite as ridiculous as the two-story translucent portraits projected during act two of THE BODYGUARD, but it came close.
I liked the transition of the story to Coney Island at the turn of the century. It gave the show its own character, even though the music thematically linked it to PHANTOM. It retained an otherworldliness without repeating the original show's setting.
The costumes and staging were uniformly very good indeed. Christine's final gown was a blue peacock fantasy, just gorgeous. The carnival costumes worked very well.
The voices were all splendid, but Meghan Picerno, who played Christine, was astonishing, sweeping the stratosphere with her coloratura. Gardar Thor Cortes, as the Phantom, had pipes that could have blown down the walls. As I progress with my voice lessons, I'm listening to and watching singers much more closely, and it's been fun to recognize techniques here and there that I've been talking about with my teacher.
Toward the end of the first act, the BIGNESS of the music began to wear on me. Intermission came just a smidge too late for me not to feel it. Every now and then I found myself thinking that the lyrics were remarkably pedestrian; I wanted a little more poetry. There were a coupe of moments that were supposed to be dramatic but provoked inappropriate laughter from more than just me. I saw the big reveal in the first act long before it came. Developments in the second act unwound in an interesting but not especially original way, although I *was* surprised by the twist at the end, not that it happened but when and how it happened.
In the end, though, as I said above, the evening did fly for me, so I enjoyed the show despite its shortcomings: melodramatic, overwrought, big Big BIG music. Sometimes, it just works anyway.
I'm still hearing the show's eponymous tune, "Love Never Dies" in my head. It, along with "Look with Your Heart" (which, I think, is sort of the point of the whole show), "Beneath a Moonless Sky," "Once Upon Another Time," "Dear Old Friend," "Bathing Beauty" and "Devil Take the Hindmost" were the most distinctive numbers, and stand out among the rest. My criticism of the lyrics and the melodrama still stands but, say what you will about Lloyd-Webber, he knows his business very well indeed.